GUNWATCHER.COM

	Dec, 2025 December 2025	Nov, 2025 November 2025	Oct, 2025 October 2025
NEW	View Current Value	$431.40 ( + $14.62 )	$416.77
USED	View Current Value	$334.96 ( - $5.55 )	$340.50

SOLD GUNS

View All Sold Data

New
Used

Price	Item	Condition	Date Sold
$300.00	PIETTA 1858 MODEL SHERIFF CABELAS 44 BLACK POWDER REVOLVER	New
$629.63	45 LC ANGEL EYES CIMARRON 1858 REMINGTON 45LC FS 8 W 44 CALIBER CYLINDER 844234239962	New
$295.00	TRADITIONS F LLI PIETTA 1858 MODEL ARMY REVOLVER BLACK POWDER 44 CAL	New
$541.16	45 COLT CIMARRON 1858 MODEL ARMY REVOLVER LONG 8 IN BLUED 6 SHOT 814230011237 KIN\|1209656 CA1000	New
$275.00	PIETTA PF58BR44512 1858 REMINGTON BRASS SHERIFF 44 CAL 6RD 5 50” BLUED 641996730184 PIETTARGBSH44129230	New
$270.08	PIETTA PF58BR44512 1858 REMINGTON BRASS SHERIFF 44 CAL 6RD 5 50 BLUED O 641996730184 SSO128859	New
$245.99	PIETTA™ 1858 REMINGTON ARMY BLACK POWDER REVOLVER 44 CALIBER 8 BARREL 745560711866 GB RGA44	New
$575.00	OTHER MODEL TAYLOR'S & CO TALORS 1858 BLACK ROCK 44CAL BP 839665001608 8 INCH BARREL	New
$503.33	CIM PREACHER 1858 REM DUAL CYL 8 45LC 44 BHCIM	New
$605.00	PIETTA 5 INCH STAINLESS 1858 44 WITH CHECKERED GRIPS	New
$225.00	F LLI PIETTA 1858 REMINGTON ARMY 44 CAL 8” PERCUSSION REVOLVER	New
$355.00	NOS UNFIRED ITALIAN PIETTA 1858 BUFFALO 44 CAL 12” BARREL	New
$300.00	NOS PIETTA CABELAS 1858 REMINGTON 44 BLACK POWDER MODEL ARMY	New
$199.00	REMINGTON 1858 STYLE BLACK POWDER REVOLVER	New

Price	Item	Condition	Date Sold
	CIMARRON 1858 NAVY – 36 CAL PERCUSSION 7 5 BARREL	Used
	1997 F LLI PIETTA MODEL 1858 REMINGTON ARMY 44 BLACK POWDER 8	Used
	ITALIAN RICHLAND ARMS 1858 TEXAS ARMY REP 44 CAL PERCUSSION REVOLVER 251112AR002	Used
	RICHLAND ARMS 1858 TEXAS ARMY 44 CAL PERCUSSION REVOLVER ANTIQUE 251104JL005	Used
	PIETTA REMINGTON MODEL ARMY 1858 44 NICKEL GOLD ENGRAVED	Used
	PIETTA 1858 44CAL BLACK POWDER REVOLVER 8” WITH HOLSTER	Used
	ITALIAN UBERTI 1858 ARMY 44 CAL BLACK POWDER 8 OCTAGON 6 SHOT FFL A55196	Used
	VINTAGE MODEL ARMY 1858 44 PERCUSSION 8 BLACK POWDER REVOLVER	Used
	ORIGINAL U S CIVIL WAR STARR ARMS CO 1858 DA 44 CALIBER PERC ARMY REV E 670 A	Used
	F LLI PIETTA 1858 REMINGTON BUFFALO 44 CAL 12” PERCUSSION REVOLVER 2002 LSB250819RF010 215	Used
	REMINGTON 1858 ARMY 44 REVOLVER NAVY ARMS CIVIL WAR PERCUSSION PISTOL	Used
	PIETTA REMINGTON 1858 ARMY 44 CAL 7 5 SINGLE ACTION MFD 2002 ANTIQUE LSB250819RF008 215	Used
	UBERTI MODEL 1858 PERCUSSION REVOLVER 44 BLACK POWDER 8” BARREL MFG 2017 4797 002	Used
	PIETTA REMINGTON 1858 ARMY 44 CALIBER 8 PERCUSSION REVOLVER MFD 2013 LSB250522DD077 1 215	Used
	PIETTA MODEL 1858 44CAL BLACK POWDER REVOLVER BID GMGC 25A518 1 205504	Used
	BP903 PIETTA 1858 REMINGTON STAINLESS TARGET 44 UNFIRED HIGH	Used
	1858 ARMY 44 EURO ARMS OF AMERICA IMPORTED TO UTICA NY BP#39	Used
	BEAUTIFUL PIETTA MODEL 1858 44CALIBER BLACK POWDER BID 641996730368 PF58BRE448	Used
	ENGRAVED 1858 REMINGTON MODEL 44 PERCUSSION REVOLVER & HOLSTER COPY	Used
	FILLI PIETTA REMINGTON 1858 ARMY SS PF58SS448 44 CAL BP REVOLVER XJ0000X N A	Used
	CABELA'S 1858 MODEL ARMY BLACK POWDER	Used
	PIETTA 1858 REMINGTON MODEL ARMY 44 BLACK POWDER 8 REVOLVER + HOLSTER 96281 1	Used
	PIETTA ITALIAN MODEL 1858 ARMY BLACK POWDER PISTOL REVOLVER 44 CAL 8 TE	Used
	ANTIQUE ORIGINAL MODEL REMINGTON 1858 REVOLVER ARMY 44 PERCUSSION	Used
	PIETTA 1858 THE ACE ARMY SNUBNOSE 44 CAL 3” PERCUSSION REVOLVER 251006DS015	Used
	PIETTA 1858 REMINGTON STAINLESS 44 CAL 8” CAP & BALL REVOLVER ATF ANTIQUE 251006DS009	Used
	UBERTI 1858 ARMY 44 CALIBER BLAC POWDER REVOLVER BLUED STEEL	Used
	NAVY ARMS 1858 REMINGTON 36 CAL BLACK POWDER REVOLVER PIETTA	Used
	BP 835 P FLLI PIETTA REMINGTON 1858 44 CAL ENGRAVED	Used
	FILLI PIETTA 1858 44 CAL BP533	Used
	REMINGTON 1858 MODEL 36 CAL PARTS CIVIL WAR	Used
	F LLI PIETTA 1858 REMINGTON 44 CAL 8” PERCUSSION REVOLVER FL01 FLLI	Used
	OTHER MODEL ENFIELD MK 1 PISTOL 38 200 S: ZJ7097 1858 2 INCH BARREL	Used
	UNMARKED 44 CAL BLACK POWDER 1858 PATTERN REVOLVER W HOLSTER –	Used
	1986 1987 PIETTA 1858 REMINGTON MODEL RATTLESNAKE COMMEMORATIVE	Used
	ANTIQUE CIVIL WAR STARR ARMS CO DOUBLE ACTION 1858 ARMY REVOLVER	Used
	CIVIL WAR ANTIQUE STARR ARMS MODEL 1858 ARMY 44 PERCUSSION CAVALRY REVOLVER	Used
	PIETTA 1858 44 CAL BLACK POWDER REVOLVER 8” BARREL W HOLSTER	Used
	PIETTA 1858 44 CAL 12” OCTAGON BARREL TEXAS BUFFALO BLACK POWDER REVOLVER	Used
	OTHER MODEL 38 SPL TAYLOR'S & CO TAYLORS 1858 38SPL	Used
	FFL BLACK FILI PIETTA REMINGTON 1858 36 CALIBER REVOLVER FROZEN MISSING	Used
	PIETTA 1858 MODEL ARMY SHERIFF 44 CAL 5 6 SHOT REVOLVER 23623053539 P7 8 26 IL	Used
	ITALIAN REMINGTON 1858 45 CAL BLACK POWDER 7 75 BBL FFL 09978	Used
	1858 ARMY 44 CAL INCLUDES WESTERN GUN BELT BLACK POWDER ITALY 01 BP#40	Used
	F LLIPIETTA NAVY ARMS 1858 ARMY 44 CAL BP34	Used
	NAVY ARMS 1858 REMINGTON REVOLVER CAL 44	Used
	OTHER MODEL 45 COLT CIMARRON 1858 ARMY 45LC REVOLVER 8 INCH BARREL	Used
	NAVY ARMS CO MODEL 1858 ARMY PERCUSSION REVOLVER 44CAL	Used
	F LLI PIETTA REMINGTON MODEL ARMY 1858 44 BPM 8 BLUED	Used
	TRADITIONS 1858 REMINGTON ARMY MUZZLELOADER PISTOL 44 CAL 8 BARREL 040589185811	Used
	BEAUTIFUL PIETTA MODEL 1858 44CALIBER BLACK POWDER BID GMGC 25A518 2 205490	Used
	CVA MODEL 1858 44BP 7 5 BRASS BLACK POWDER REVOLVER	Used
	EUROARMS OF AMERICA REMINGTON 1858 MODEL 44 CAL	Used
	CONNETICUT VALLEY ARMS CVA 1858 ARMY 44 CAL BLACK POWDER REVOLVER PISTOL	Used
	NAVY ARMS 1858 36 CAL BLACK POWDER	Used
	BP659 EURO ARMS REMINGTON 1858 ARMY CAP AND BALL REVOLVER	Used
	NAVY ARMS 1858 PERCUSSION BLACK POWDER 44 CAL ENGRAVED CASE	Used
	PIETTA MODEL 1858 44CAL BLACK POWDER REVOLVER BID GMGC 25A518 1 205504	Used
	OTHER MODEL ASM 44CAL REVOLVER REMINGTON 1858 CAP AND BALL BLACK POWDER FFL REQUIRED 8 INCH BARREL	Used
	DIXIE GUN WORKS F LLI PIETTA 1858 MODEL TEXAS CL 44 CAL 8 OCT BRL WI 2604 09	Used
	EUROARMS OF AMERICA REMINGTON 1858 MODEL 44 CAL BLACK POWDER REVOLVER BPS074675	Used
	UBERTI ITALIAN REMINGTON 1858 44 BLACK POWDER 8 COLT #SE200 B	Used
	PIETTA MODEL 1858 ARMY STAINLESS STEEL 44 CALIBER BLACK POWDER GTOPARTS	Used
	OTHER MODEL 38 SPL CIMARRON CIMMARON 1858 NAVY 7 3 8 BARREL 844234100453 INCH CA1010	Used
	REMINGTON MODEL 1858 ANTIQUE REVOLVER 44 CAL	Used
	ANTIQUE CIVIL WAR STARR ARMS CO DOUBLE ACTION 1858 ARMY REVOLVER	Used
	REMINGTON 1858 MODEL ARMY 44 REVOLVER REPLICA UNFIRED FFL	Used
	UBERTI 1858 ARMY BLACKPOWDER STAINLESS 250120872	Used
	UBERTI REMINGTON MODEL 1858 ARMY 44 CAL STAINLESS	Used
	STARR ARMS 1858 ARMY REVOLVER ORIGINAL CIVIL WAR ERA 44 CAL	Used
	BP881 PIETTA ITALY REMINGTON 1858 TARGET 44 CAP AND BALL REVOLVER	Used
	CONNECTICUT VALLEY ARMS 1858 ARMY 44CAL BLACK POWDER REVOLVER PISTOL	Used
	F LLI PIETTA REMINGTON MODEL ARMY 1858 44 BPM 8 BLUED	Used
	2 OF 5000 SPORTSMAN'S GUIDE PIETTA 1858 REMINGTON 44CAL 1¢	Used
	UBERTI 1858 ARMY BLACK POWDER 44	Used
	PIETTA 1858 NAVY BLACK POWDER 44 WITH TAYLOR CYLINDER BEAUTIFUL 01	Used
	PIETTA 1858 ARMY 44 CAL 8IN REVOLVER	Used
	PIETTA REMINGTON 1858 MODEL ARMY SINGLE ACTION 44 CAL 8 W HOLSTER LSB250728DD014 209	Used
	ARMI SAN MARCO MODEL 1858 REMINGTON 44 CALIBER 8” PERCUSSION REVOLVER 1990 LSB250723CA151 209	Used
	ARMI SAN MARCO CASED PAIR REMINGTON 1858 44 CAL 8 PERCUSSION REVOLVERS LSB250727AM102 & LSB250727AM103	Used
	OTHER MODEL CIMARRON 1858 ARMY — 45 COLT 8 BARREL SINGLE ACTION 844234130412 INCH CA1000N00	Used
	REPRODUCTION CIVIL WAR REMINGTON 1858 ARMY REVOLVER	Used

1858 GUN VALUES

CURRENT MARKET PRICE

SOLD GUNS

IN STOCK NOW